
Lani Kai Beachfront Resort
Best for beach-centered stays, families, and guests who want on-site restaurants and bars with Gulf views.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Lani Kai Beachfront Resort is a family-owned beachfront resort on Fort Myers Beach with rooftop restaurants, lively beach bars, and family-friendly amenities — a good pick for beach-focused families and groups. Inn on Fifth is a polished 4-star boutique hotel in downtown Naples for travelers who want walkable dining, shopping, and a full-service spa experience.
Updated · about 50 km apart

Best for beach-centered stays, families, and guests who want on-site restaurants and bars with Gulf views.

Best for a polished downtown Naples stay with easy access to Fifth Avenue South's shops and restaurants and an on-site full-service spa.
When Lani Kai Beachfront Resort wins: choose Lani Kai if your priority is staying directly on the Gulf with rooftop and beach bars, family-friendly activities, and straightforward beachfront access.
When Inn on Fifth wins: choose Inn on Fifth if you want a boutique, downtown Naples base for dining and shopping, a full-service spa, and a compact hotel within walking distance of Fifth Avenue South and Naples Beach.
Bottom line: pick Lani Kai for an active, restaurant-and-beach-first vacation on Fort Myers Beach; pick Inn on Fifth for a more refined downtown Naples experience focused on dining, shopping, and spa time.
| Category | Lani Kai Beachfront Resort | Inn on Fifth |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Lively beachfront resort with rooftop restaurants, bars, and regular live entertainment. | Quiet, polished boutique hotel focused on dining, shopping access, and spa services. |
| Location | Directly on the Gulf at 1400 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach (over 400 feet of beachfront). | In downtown Old Naples at 699 5th Ave S; steps from Fifth Avenue South and a ~12-minute walk to Naples Beach. |
| Size | 100 rooms across 6 floors (exterior corridors). | 119 guestrooms (interior corridors). |
| Ages / audience | Family-owned, welcomes guests of all ages; kids' playground and children's menu available. | Not adults-only; welcomes families and general guests (adults-focused boutique positioning). |
| Pools & beach | One outdoor heated pool for registered guests and over 400 feet of Gulf beachfront with beach chair/umbrella service (fees may apply). | One outdoor pool plus a hot tub; complimentary beach shuttle to Naples Beach. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues: Sun Deck Restaurant (rooftop), Grace's Trattoria (Italian), Island View Sports Bar, 3 beachfront bars, coffee shop and snack options. | One on-site restaurant and a bar/lounge; room service (limited hours) and cooked-to-order breakfast available for a fee. |
| Spa & wellness | No evidence of a named on-site spa or gym; pool is the primary onsite recreation. | Full-service spa offering massages, body treatments, and facials; 24-hour fitness facilities listed. |
| Known for | Direct Gulf access, rooftop dining and multiple beach bars with live entertainment. | Location on Fifth Avenue South, boutique feel, spa, and walkable dining/shopping. |
| Parking & fees | Self-parking available (USD 20/night, limited to one space per reservation) and a mandatory resort fee (approx. USD 22.30/night). | Valet parking available for a surcharge (listed USD 40/day); optional fees for breakfast and pet fees may apply. |
Lani Kai sits directly on Estero Boulevard with over 400 feet of Gulf beachfront and easy access to Fort Myers Beach's Times Square and pier area.
Choose Lani Kai if you want immediate beach access and an active resort strip location on Estero Island.
Inn on Fifth is located on Fifth Avenue South in Old Naples, putting shops, galleries, and restaurants within a short walk.
Choose Inn on Fifth for a compact, walkable downtown location with easy access to Naples dining and shopping.
Lani Kai offers three beachfront room types with options that include kitchenettes or full kitchens for longer stays.
Choose Lani Kai for beachfront rooms with kitchen options useful for families or longer stays.
Inn on Fifth has a wide mix of room types across its 119 guestrooms, from deluxe doubles to multi-bedroom suites and club-level rooms.
Choose Inn on Fifth for a greater variety of boutique-style room types and several suite/club upgrades.
Lani Kai provides on-site variety: rooftop restaurants, Italian dining, an energetic sports bar, beachfront bars, and casual café options.
Lani Kai is strong when you want to stay on property for most meals and enjoy beachfront bar scenes and rooftop views.
Inn on Fifth is positioned for guests who plan to explore downtown dining but also want an on-site restaurant and bar.
Inn on Fifth suits travelers who expect to eat out in Naples' downtown restaurants but like a reliable hotel dining option and bar.
Lani Kai centers on beach access and a single outdoor heated pool with pool loungers and umbrellas for guests.
Pick Lani Kai for immediate Gulf access, beachfront dining service, and an active beach-bar scene.
Inn on Fifth offers a compact outdoor pool, hot tub and easy access to Naples Beach via a short walk or complimentary beach shuttle.
Choose Inn on Fifth if you want a downtown hotel with pool and quick shuttle access to the beach rather than beachfront rooms.
Lani Kai's on-site entertainment is focused on beach bars, live music, and sports-bar nightlife rather than a spa.
Lani Kai is for guests who prefer beachside nightlife and casual evening entertainment rather than a dedicated spa retreat.
Inn on Fifth includes a full-service spa and quieter evening options centered on downtown dining and the hotel's bar/lounge.
Choose Inn on Fifth if spa treatments and a quieter, adult-leaning evening are priorities.

Lani Kai — direct Gulf frontage with over 400 feet of beach and on-site beach chair/umbrella service.

Inn on Fifth — steps from Fifth Avenue South's restaurants, galleries, and shops.

Lani Kai — suites and studios with kitchenettes/full kitchens, children's menu, playground, and family activities.

Inn on Fifth — on-site full-service spa, club and suite room categories, and a polished downtown setting.
Lani Kai Beachfront Resort is directly on the Gulf with beachfront access; Inn on Fifth is in downtown Naples and is a short walk from Naples Beach (about 12 minutes).
No — both properties welcome guests of all ages. Lani Kai is family-owned with kids' facilities; Inn on Fifth is not adults-only.
Inn on Fifth lists a full-service spa. Public sources do not show a named spa or fitness center at Lani Kai.
Lani Kai has more on-site dining and multiple bars including rooftop and beachfront options; Inn on Fifth has one on-site restaurant and a bar and is best paired with downtown dining on Fifth Avenue.
Explore how Lani Kai Beachfront Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·