
Lani Kai Beachfront Resort
Best for families and travelers who want direct Gulf-front beach access and rooftop dining right over the water.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Lani Kai Beachfront Resort is a family-owned, Gulf-front Fort Myers Beach hotel with direct beach access, a rooftop restaurant, one outdoor heated pool and family-focused programming. Naples Bay Resort & Marina is an upscale Naples resort and marina with multiple pools, on-site marina access and several dining outlets; read this if you’re deciding between a straight beachfront, family-oriented stay (Lani Kai) and a marina-forward, full-service Naples option (Naples Bay).
Updated

Best for families and travelers who want direct Gulf-front beach access and rooftop dining right over the water.

Best for travelers who want a marina-front base in Naples with multiple pools, a full-service spa and on-site boating options.
When Lani Kai Beachfront Resort wins: Choose Lani Kai when your priority is stepping straight onto the Gulf, having compact resort grounds with a single heated pool, active beachfront bars and family-friendly programming.
When Naples Bay Resort & Marina wins: Pick Naples Bay Resort & Marina when you want a larger, upscale property with extensive pool options, a marina and more on-site dining and wellness facilities.
Bottom line: For a classic Gulf-beach, family-first Fort Myers Beach stay with rooftop views, Lani Kai is the practical choice; for a larger resort experience centered on a marina, more pools and a spa in Naples, choose Naples Bay Resort & Marina.
| Category | Lani Kai Beachfront Resort | Naples Bay Resort & Marina |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Casual, family-owned beachfront resort with lively beach bars and rooftop dining. | Upscale, marina-front Naples resort with multiple pools and full-service amenities. |
| Location | Directly on the Gulf at 1400 Estero Blvd, close to Fort Myers Beach’s Times Square and the pier. | Centrally located in Naples at 1500 Fifth Ave S, close to Fifth Avenue South and Naples Bay. |
| Size (rooms) | 100 rooms across 6 floors. | 87 guestrooms. |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome — family-focused with a gated playground and children’s menus (minimum check-in age 21). | All ages welcome (family-friendly; not adults-only). |
| Pools | One outdoor heated pool for registered guests. | Five outdoor pools plus children’s pool and hot tub(s). |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: Sun Deck Restaurant (rooftop), Grace's Trattoria (Italian), Island View Sports Bar, plus several beachfront bars and cafes. | Four restaurants, a coffee shop/café and three bars/lounges, including the Blue Water Bar and Grill. |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa or fitness center listed. | Full-service spa with treatments and a health club; fitness classes on site. |
| Known for | Direct Gulf frontage with over 400 feet of beach, rooftop dining and live beachfront entertainment. | Marina on site, extensive pool options and concierge services for boating and waterfront activities. |
| Accessibility & family services | Family-oriented amenities (playground, children’s menu) and wheelchair-accessible parking; pets not allowed. | Wheelchair accessible public areas, pool hoist, accessible rooms and family-friendly policies; offers babysitting (surcharge). |
| Event & wedding space | Multiple indoor/outdoor wedding and event venues including rooftop and beachfront options (capacities for small to large groups). | Banquet halls, meeting rooms and full event services suited to weddings and business events. |
Lani Kai sits directly on Estero Boulevard with over 400 feet of Gulf frontage and easy pedestrian access to Times Square and the pier.
Best if you want immediate Gulf beach access and easy, walkable access to Fort Myers Beach attractions.
Naples Bay Resort & Marina sits in central Naples with quick access to Fifth Avenue South and the city’s waterfront district.
Best if you want a city-center location with marina access and easy access to Naples dining and shopping.
Lani Kai’s room lineup focuses on beachfront orientation and a small set of room types with kitchen options for longer stays.
Choose Lani Kai for straightforward beachfront rooms and suites with kitchenette/full-kitchen options for families or longer stays.
Naples Bay offers a larger selection of suite types and marina- or waterway-view rooms, with accessible-room options.
Choose Naples Bay if you want suite-style accommodations and specific marina or waterway views.
Lani Kai has multiple on-site venues ranging from casual cafes to rooftop dining and several beachfront bars.
Lani Kai emphasizes beachfront and rooftop dining with a mix of casual and sit-down options geared to families and groups.
Naples Bay provides multiple on-site restaurants and bars, including American options and poolside venues.
Naples Bay suits travelers who want more on-site dining variety and a polished restaurant/bar lineup in Naples.
Lani Kai’s main water feature is its single outdoor heated pool and immediate Gulf beachfront.
Lani Kai is for guests who prioritize beach time and a compact pool footprint tied directly to Gulf access.
Naples Bay’s standout amenities are its marina and multiple outdoor pools across the property.
Naples Bay is for travelers who want varied pool options plus on-site marina activities and optional beach access via shuttle.
Lani Kai focuses on casual beachfront entertainment rather than a formal spa or fitness center.
Expect lively beach and rooftop nightlife at Lani Kai, but no full-service spa or gym on site.
Naples Bay offers a fuller wellness and service program including a full-service spa and fitness options.
Naples Bay is better if you want spa treatments, fitness classes and fuller on-site resort services.

Lani Kai — over 400 feet of beachfront and immediate Gulf access from the property.

Naples Bay Resort & Marina — marina on site plus water-sport and boating options.

Naples Bay Resort & Marina — five outdoor pools, a children’s pool and hot tub(s).

Lani Kai — rooftop Sun Deck Restaurant, multiple beachfront bars and chair-side beach service.
Lani Kai is explicitly family-focused with a gated playground, children’s menus and family beach activities; Naples Bay also welcomes families but is more of an upscale marina resort with babysitting available for a surcharge.
Lani Kai offers Studio Beachfront rooms with a kitchenette and Beachfront Suites with full kitchens; Naples Bay has a variety of suites but kitchen availability depends on the specific residence or suite type listed.
No — Naples Bay Resort & Marina sits on Naples Bay with an on-site marina and offers a complimentary beach shuttle to Naples Beach rather than direct oceanfront rooms.
Lani Kai charges a mandatory resort fee (approximately USD 22.30 per night) and a paid self-parking fee (USD 20 per night); Naples Bay lists valet parking as a surcharge and other optional fees — check each property’s current policies before booking.
Explore how Lani Kai Beachfront Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·