
Lani Kai Beachfront Resort
Best for families or groups who want multiple on-site restaurants, beach bars and active beachfront entertainment.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Lani Kai Beachfront Resort is a family-owned, Gulf-front resort on Fort Myers Beach with multiple restaurants, beach bars, a rooftop terrace and one outdoor heated pool — good for families and groups who want lively beachfront dining and on-site entertainment. Sanibel Inn is a classic 3-star beach inn on Sanibel Island with private beach access, an outdoor pool and Dante’s Restaurant — read this if you’re weighing a Fort Myers Beach stay against the quieter, island feel of Sanibel.
Updated · about 11.6 miles (≈18.7 km) apart

Best for families or groups who want multiple on-site restaurants, beach bars and active beachfront entertainment.

Best for travelers who prefer a small, classic island inn with private beach access and quieter Sanibel surroundings.
When Lani Kai wins: Choose Lani Kai Beachfront Resort if you want direct Fort Myers Beach energy — multiple restaurants and bars (including rooftop and beach bars), daily live entertainment options, and family-oriented activities right on a long stretch of Gulf beachfront.
When Sanibel Inn wins: Choose Sanibel Inn if you want a smaller, classic Sanibel property with private beach access, rooms with kitchen facilities, and an island setting that’s closer to Sanibel’s shelling and natural attractions.
Bottom line: Lani Kai is the pick for a full-service, active beachfront resort experience on Fort Myers Beach; Sanibel Inn suits travelers seeking a lower-key island inn with private beach and compact grounds on Sanibel.
| Category | Lani Kai Beachfront Resort | Sanibel Inn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Lively, full-service beachfront resort with rooftop dining and multiple bars | Classic, low-rise island inn with a relaxed beach-inn atmosphere |
| Location | On Estero Boulevard, directly on Fort Myers Beach near Times Square and the pier | On Sanibel (East End), on a private beach at 937 East Gulf Drive |
| Size (rooms) | 100 rooms across 6 floors | 95 rooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 for the person booking | |
| Pools | One outdoor heated pool for guests | One outdoor pool and private beach access |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple (3 restaurants, 6+ bars including 3 beach bars, a cafe and rooftop venues) | Dante’s Restaurant plus a bar/lounge and a poolside bar (one on-site restaurant) |
| Spa & fitness | No on-site full spa or fitness center published | Not published |
| Known for | Rooftop dining, active beachfront bars, live entertainment, family facilities | Private beach, rooms with kitchens, compact island location near Sanibel Moorings Botanical Gardens |
| Parking & fees | Self-parking available (fee) and a mandatory resort fee applies (~USD 22.30/night) | Noted mandatory resort fee (USD 50.18/night) and parking details published in supplier listing |
Lani Kai sits directly on Estero Boulevard with over 400 feet of Gulf beachfront and is within walking distance of Fort Myers Beach’s Times Square and the pier.
Choose Lani Kai for immediate Fort Myers Beach access and easy access to the pier, shops and ferry services.
Sanibel Inn is on Sanibel’s east end with private beach access and short walks to Sanibel Island Southern Beach and local gardens.
Choose Sanibel Inn for a quieter island setting with private beach access and proximity to Sanibel’s natural attractions.
Lani Kai offers three beachfront room types including suites with full kitchens and studios with kitchenettes.
Pick Lani Kai if you want beachfront rooms with kitchen options and easy access to resort amenities.
Sanibel Inn’s 95 air-conditioned rooms include many with kitchen facilities and are set in a low-rise, compact layout.
Pick Sanibel Inn if you want island-style rooms with full kitchen facilities for longer stays or light meal prep.
Lani Kai has multiple on-site dining venues from casual cafe to rooftop and several beach bars.
Lani Kai is for guests who want a broad range of on-site dining and active bar scenes without leaving the property.
Sanibel Inn features Dante’s Restaurant for on-site dining plus a bar/lounge and a poolside bar.
Sanibel Inn fits travelers who want a compact, on-site dining option and easy access to island restaurants nearby.
Lani Kai provides one outdoor heated pool plus direct Gulf-front beach with loungers, umbrellas and staffed beach food service.
Lani Kai is a better fit if you want an active beach scene and on-site beach dining options.
Sanibel Inn offers an outdoor pool and private beach access on Sanibel Island.
Sanibel Inn is preferable for guests seeking a quieter beach experience focused on shelling and relaxed shoreline time.
Lani Kai emphasizes bars, live entertainment and casual beachfront nightlife rather than a formal spa or gym.
Choose Lani Kai for nightlife, live entertainment and casual evening options, not for spa or gym facilities.
Sanibel Inn’s on-site options focus on low-key evenings and island pacing, with no published on-site spa mentioned in supplier listing.
Sanibel Inn works for guests who want quieter nights and island activities; spa services are not published on-site.

Lani Kai — family-friendly facilities, kids’ menu, playground and active beachfront programming.

Sanibel Inn — private beach access and a low-rise inn atmosphere close to Sanibel’s nature and shelling spots.

Lani Kai — multiple restaurants, rooftop dining and several beach bars give you many choices without leaving the property.

Sanibel Inn — many room types include full kitchens with refrigerators, freezers and ovens for self-catering.
Lani Kai is set up for families with a gated playground, children’s menus and family beach activities; Sanibel Inn accepts families but has a quieter, small-inn feel.
Neither property publishes a full spa on-site; Lani Kai’s dossier shows no on-site spa or fitness center, and Sanibel Inn’s supplier listing does not list a spa.
Both have direct beach access: Lani Kai on Fort Myers Beach with a long Gulf frontage and active beach bars; Sanibel Inn offers private beach access in a quieter island setting.
They’re roughly 11.6 miles (≈18.7 km) apart — a short transfer from Fort Myers Beach to Sanibel via the Sanibel Causeway.
Explore how Lani Kai Beachfront Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·