
Lani Kai Beachfront Resort
Best for families and travelers who want direct Gulf-front rooms, rooftop restaurants, and on-site beach entertainment.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Lani Kai Beachfront Resort is a family-owned, full-service beachfront resort on Estero Boulevard for travelers who want direct Gulf access, rooftop dining, and lively beach bars. The Lighthouse Resort Inn & Suites is a casual, central Fort Myers Beach inn with multiple suite layouts and two outdoor pools — a good pick for travelers wanting a familiar, budget-conscious beach stay near Times Square.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for families and travelers who want direct Gulf-front rooms, rooftop restaurants, and on-site beach entertainment.

Best for travelers who want a casual, central Fort Myers Beach base with a variety of suite options and multiple pools.
When Lani Kai Beachfront Resort wins: choose Lani Kai if you prioritize direct Gulf-front access, a rooftop restaurant with views (Sun Deck), multiple on-site restaurants and bars, and family-friendly facilities like a gated playground and children's menu.
When The Lighthouse Resort Inn & Suites wins: choose The Lighthouse if you want suite-style rooms (including 2-bedroom and family suites), two outdoor pools, free self parking, and a more budget-minded, casual inn in the heart of Fort Myers Beach.
Bottom line: Lani Kai is the better option for a full beachfront resort experience, dining variety, and family amenities; The Lighthouse is a solid, no-frills alternative for travelers after suite layouts and extra pool options close to Times Square.
| Category | Lani Kai Beachfront Resort | The Lighthouse Resort Inn & Suites |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Full-service, family-owned beachfront resort with active beach & rooftop venues | Casual resort-style inn with a familiar, central Fort Myers Beach feel |
| Location | Directly on the Gulf of Mexico at 1400 Estero Blvd (beachfront near Times Square) | Near the beach at 1051 5th St, within a short walk of Times Square and Estero Boulevard |
| Size (rooms) | 100 rooms across 6 floors | 75 guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | Welcomes families; minimum check-in age 21 | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age listed as 23 in supplier policies |
| Pools | One outdoor heated pool for registered guests | Two outdoor pools |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: Grace's Cafe, Grace's Trattoria, Sun Deck Restaurant, Island View Sports Bar, three beachfront bars and more | One restaurant and one bar/lounge on site (plus poolside bar); room service available during limited hours |
| Spa / fitness | No evidence of an on-site spa or fitness center | Not published |
| Known for | Extensive beachfront (400+ feet), rooftop dining and live entertainment | Central, recognizable Fort Myers Beach name with a variety of family-friendly suite types |
| Parking & transport | Limited paid self-parking (USD 20/night) and trolley stop nearby; resort fee applies | Free self parking available (limited spaces); front desk staffed limited hours |
| Free WiFi | Free high-speed WiFi throughout the resort, including in rooms | |
Lani Kai sits directly on the Gulf with over 400 feet of private beachfront and is steps from Times Square and the pier area.
Pick Lani Kai if you want true beachfront rooms and immediate Gulf access.
The Lighthouse is a casual Fort Myers Beach inn located close to Estero Boulevard attractions and a short walk to the beach.
Pick The Lighthouse for a central, walkable Fort Myers Beach location with straightforward beach access.
Lani Kai offers three beachfront room types, including suites with full kitchens and studios with kitchenettes.
Lani Kai is best if beachfront rooms and in-room kitchen options matter.
The Lighthouse has a range of suite layouts geared toward families and longer stays.
The Lighthouse is best if you want more suite types and larger room options.
Lani Kai offers multiple on-site restaurants and bars, including rooftop dining and several beachfront bars.
Lani Kai has more on-site dining and bar choices, useful if you prefer to eat on property.
The Lighthouse has on-site dining but on a smaller scale.
The Lighthouse covers basics for dining on site but fewer venue choices than Lani Kai.
Lani Kai operates one outdoor heated pool plus direct beach access and multiple beach bars and activities.
Choose Lani Kai for a combined beach-and-pool resort experience focused on the Gulf.
The Lighthouse lists two outdoor pools and a poolside bar as part of its amenities.
The Lighthouse offers more pool space if pool variety matters more than direct beachfront rooms.
Lani Kai combines family-friendly daytime activities with evening live entertainment and lively beach bars.
Lani Kai leans into beach entertainment and family activities rather than spa or gym services.
The Lighthouse focuses on straightforward leisure features rather than a full wellness program.
The Lighthouse covers basic leisure needs; a dedicated spa or fitness center is not published.

Lani Kai — direct Gulf-front rooms and over 400 feet of private beachfront.

The Lighthouse — many suite configurations including 2-bedroom and family suites.

Lani Kai — multiple restaurants, rooftop dining, beachfront bars and a café.

The Lighthouse — two outdoor pools and a poolside bar.
Both are within easy walking distance of Times Square and Estero Boulevard attractions; The Lighthouse sits in a central spot on 5th Street while Lani Kai is directly on Estero Boulevard near the pier.
Lani Kai offers Studio Beachfront rooms with kitchenettes and Beachfront Suites with full kitchens; The Lighthouse listing includes several suite types that may have kitchenette-style arrangements, but specifics vary by room type.
No evidence shows an on-site spa at Lani Kai; The Lighthouse supplier listing does not publish a spa either.
Lani Kai is clearly family-oriented (gated playground, children's menu, family beach games). The Lighthouse lists family-friendly suites but offers fewer family-dedicated facilities on its supplier listing.
Explore how Lani Kai Beachfront Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·